The Extent of Arbitration's Preference and Independence over the Judicial System in Disputes Resolution Selection: A Re-Evaluation for Developing Judiciary and Arbitration Systems
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21093/mj.v18i2.1450Abstract
The arbitration system is considered to be the most effective and efficient way of dispute resolution than the judicial litigation system. This opinion is based on several reasons such as time speed, confidentiality, flexibility, and so forth. Therefore, arbitration is considered to be able to present preference and independence in dispute resolution. However, this assumption needs to be assessed scientifically in accordance with existing realities. Hence, this article is to compare between the arbitration and other litigation systems in terms of their advantages and disadvantages. It found that arbitration was present in response to the weaknesses of the rigid justice system and its lack of creativity in creating mechanisms for disputes between disputing parties. Despite the fact, the arbitration system, in some cases, does not have independence precisely because of its flexibility, confidentiality and lack of supervision. Thus this article confirms that the actual arbitration system does not have preferences and independence that far exceeds the general litigation justice system. In other words, the advantages of the arbitration system do not exceed that of the general justice system except for its flexibility in handling unique disputes.
Keywords: Arbitration system – Judicial system – needs of developing for resolving the disputes.
Downloads
References
Al- QÄnÅ«n al-LÄ«bÄ«, no. (4), 1981, bi sha’n al-MahÄmÄt al-Sha‘biyyah
Al-‘ahd al-DawlÄ« li al-huqÅ«q al-Madaniyyah wa al-SiyÄsiyyah, year 1966
IttifÄqiyyah al-RiyÄh li al-Ta‘Äwun al-QahÄ’ī, year 1983
IttifÄqiyyah New York li al-TanfÄ«dh al-AhkÄm al-Ajnabiyyah, year 1985
AbÅ« al-Wafī’, Ahmad. (n.d.). Al-Tahkim fÄ« QawÄnÄ«n al-BilÄd al-‘Arabiyyah. Alexandria: Al-Ma‘Ärif, 1st edn.
A‘bÅ«dah Al-KawnÄ«, ‘AlÄ«. (1991). QÄnÅ«n ‘Ilm al-QahÄ’. Tripoli: JÄmi‘ah NÄhir, 1st edn.
Al-Ahdab, ‘Abd al-HamÄ«d. (n.d.). Mawsū‘ah al-TahkÄ«m, Al-TahkÄ«m al-DawlÄ«. DÄr al-Ma‘Ārif.
Al-haddÄd, hafÄ«hah al-Sayyid. (2001). Al-IttifÄq ‘alÄ al-TahkÄ«m fÄ« ‘UqÅ«d al-Dawlah dhÄt al-Thabī‘ah al-’IdÄriyyah wa ’AtsÄruh ‘alÄ al-QÄnÅ«n al-WÄjib al-TathbÄ«q. Alexandria: DÄr al-Mathba‘Ät al-JÄmi‘iyyah, 2001.
AbÅ« GhÄbah, KhÄlid ‘Abd al-‘AzhÄ«m. Al-TahkÄ«m wa Atsaruh fÄ« Fadh al-MunÄza‘Ät. Alexandria: DÄr al-Fikr al-JÄmi‘ī, 1st ed. 2011.
RidhwÄn, AbÅ« Zayd. Al-’AsÄs al-‘Āmmah li al-TaḥkÄ«m al-TijÄrÄ« al-DawlÄ«. DÄr al-KitÄb al-hadÄ«ts, 1996.
Zakiyy, MahmÅ«d JamÄl. Al-Khibrah fÄ« al-MawÄd al-Madaniyyah wa al-TijÄriyyah, DirÄsah IntiqÄdiyyah. Cairo: Mathba‘ah JÄmi‘ah al-QÄhirah, 1990.
ShÄdiq, HishÄm; ‘UkÄsyah, ‘Abd al-’Āl. Al-QÄnÅ«n al-DawlÄ« al-KhÄsh. Alexandria: DÄr al-Mathbū‘Ät al-JÄmi‘iyyah, 2007.
Al-BathÄyinah, ‘Āmir FathÄ«. (2009). Dawr al-QÄdhÄ« fÄ« al-TahkÄ«m al-TijÄrÄ« al-DawlÄ«. Oman: DÄr al-TsaqÄfah, 2nd ed.
KhadhrÄwÄ«, ‘Uqbah. QawÄnÄ«n al-TahkÄ«m fÄ« al-Duwal al-‘Arabiyyah. Alexandria: Maktabah Al-WafÄ’, 1st ed, 2014.
‘Umar, NabÄ«l IsmÄ‘īl. Al-NizhÄm al-QÄnÅ«nÄ« li al-hukm al-QadhÄ’i. Alexandria: DÄr al-JÄmi‘ah al-JadÄ«dah, 2006.
SÄmÄ«, FawzÄ« Muhammad. Al-TahkÄ«m al-TijÄrÄ« al-DawlÄ«. Oman: DÄr al-TsaqÄfah, 5th ed, 2010.
DuwaydÄr, Thal’at. DhamÄnÄt al-taqÄdhÄ« fÄ« KhusÅ«mah al-TahkÄ«m, 2009.
Al-‘awÄ, Muhammad SalÄ«m. DirÄsÄt fÄ« QÄnÅ«n al-TahkÄ«m al-MishrÄ« wa al-MuqÄran. Egypt: DÄr al-JÄmi‘ah al-JadÄ«dah, 2007.
KhÄlid, HishÄm. JadwÄ al-Lujū’ ’ilÄ al-TahkÄ«m al-TijÄrÄ« al-DawlÄ«. Alexandria: Mansh’ah al-Ma‘Ärif, 2007.
HindÄ«, Ahmad. Al-Ta‘lÄq ‘alÄ QÄnÅ«n al-MurÄfa‘Ät. Egypt: DÄr al-JÄmi‘ah al-JadÄ«dah, 2008.
Badr, Ä€mÄl. Al-RaqÄbah al-QadhÄ’iyyah ‘alÄ al-TahkÄ«m al-TijÄrÄ« al-DawlÄ«. Beirut: ManshÅ«rat al-halabÄ« al-huqÅ«qiyyah, 1st edn, 2012.
Al-MushÄrawah, YÅ«suf. TasbÄ«b al-AhkÄm. Oman: DÄr al-TsaqÄfah, 2nd ed, 2010.
WizÄrah al-‘Adl al-LubnÄniyyah. Al-IkhtinÄq al-Qadh’ī fÄ« lubnÄn, 1994.
MunaÌÌamah al-‘AdÉlah; Mu’assasah FarÊd RÊs. (2013). Al-’Amn al-QaÌÉ’Ê wa Jawdah al-AÃkÉm.
Ma‘rÅ«f, Faraj Ahmad. Buth’ al-Batt fÄ« al-Da‘wÄ â€“ Al-IkhtishÄsh al-QadhÄ’ī. Proceeding for 7th Arab Union Conference, 2016.
Al-hÄfÄ«, Muhammad. Al-QadhÄ’ al-MÄni‘ fÄ« TanfÄ«d hukm al-TahkÄ«m fÄ« Lybia. Lybian Supreme Court Website. (n.d.).
TaqrÄ«r Lajnah al-’Umam al-Muttahidah. Al-Dawrah al-TÄsi‘ah, 2016.
MitrÄ«, MÅ«sÄ; AdÄ«b, MayÄlah. Al-TahkÄ«m fÄ« al-‘AmaliyyÄt al-Mashrafiyyah fÄ« al-Duwal dzÄt Al-’IqtishÄd al-Mutahawwal; Al-MithÄl al-SÅ«rÄ«. Paper published in Majallah JÄmi‘ah Dimashq li al-‘UlÅ«m al-IqtishÄdiyyah wa al-QÄnÅ«niyyah, vol. 26, no. 1. 2010.
Hukm al-Maḥkamah al-‘UlyÄ al-LÄ«biyyah fÄ« al-Tha‘n al-MadanÄ«, no. 54, 1989.
Majmū‘ah AhkÄm Mahkamah al-Naqdh. Hukm Mahkamah al-NaqÃŒ al-Mishriyyah fÄ« al-Naqdh al-MadanÄ«, 1971, 1978, and 2001.
Hukm Mahkamah al-’Isti’nÄf fÄ« France, 2016.
Hukm al-Mahkamah al-’IdÄriyyah bi al-RibÄth, no. 1650. 2017.
.png){kind=logo}
